It’s a while now since Google made their first foray into the Smartphone market and most commentators we in agreement that the fist Google phone, or first phone using Google’s Android operating system, was something of a disappointment. Clunky and unwieldy to use, a lack of any innovative features the G1 didn’t quite live up to the hype.
So now the second incarnation has arrived, in the form of the Vodafone HTC Magic, is it just an upgrade or a major re-working of an ambitious project?
Well, the answer is neither; the new phone is a radical departure from the first conception but anyone expecting anything radical might be further disappointed.
What’s New Then?
The QWERTY keyboard has gone and been replaced with a touch-screen version which works in both portrait and landscape formats. Tapping a key on the screen brings-up a preview of the letter which can be changed by simply dragging to another key and there is a quite efficient predictive text feature which seems to make a decent job of guessing the word to be typed. After a bit of practice you can easily type with one hand which will be welcomed by most critics who found the lack of this to be a major drawback with the G1?
The Features
The camera is still 3.2 megapixels with autofocus although it now supports video which was another omission and major gripe with the G1. The quality of images captured is fair to good, but not outstanding; although for most users it should be acceptable.
The web browser, which has to be said, was quite good on the G1 has been improved further with a new Javascript engine which makes page load speeds impressively fast. The search bar has also been merged with the address bar which seems more logical and incorporates a text search function which suggests potential matches as you type.
Call quality seems to be quite reasonable and the phone seems to find and hold the 3G signal fairly consistently and battery life has been improved dramatically. They quote around 400 minutes of talk-time between charges and this seems to be accurate. Although how fast this deteriorates as the battery gets older remains to be seen?
Another popular complaint with the original phone was a lack of standard headphone jack - employing instead a non-standard connector. Unfortunately this remains but whether it’s a major drawback depends how you listen to your music really?
Of course the real selling point of the HTC Magic is not the phone but the Android operating system. The number of applications available is growing steadily and this is, perhaps, this phone’s strongest point. Because Android is ‘open source’ there are new apps being developed everyday and existing ones are constantly being updated.
The Verdict
So overall, the HTC Magic will not set the world on fire, the Google phone project is beginning to look like a process of evolution rather than revolution?
However, it does everything it’s supposed to reasonably well and it’s a lot more user friendly and better looking than the G1. If you are happy with your existing smart phone then hang on to it for now, but if you are in the market anyway, you could do a lot worse than the HTC Magic.
The HTC Magic is available free on contract from Vodafone